
The National Center for Public Health and Pharmacy identified instances of negligence and violations of documentation regulations at the Dél-Budai Centrumkórház Szent Imre Egyetemi Oktatókórház (Szent Imre Hospital). The National Center for Public Health and Pharmacy (NCPHP) is responsible for overseeing the country’s hospitals, monitoring pharmaceuticals, and managing public health crises. A probe by NCPHP into the Szent Imre Hospital was triggered after the son of an elderly woman who died from heart attack reported that he believed his mother received negligent care and filed a formal complaint with the authority. The health authority identified instances of negligence and violations of documentation regulations.
“Our authority imposed a 500,000 HUF healthcare fine—which the institution paid—and required the provider to fully comply with professional standards, particularly regarding the thorough assessment for hospital admission,”
the NCPHP wrote in its response to Direkt36’s request.
Help us tell the truth in Hungary! Become a supporter now and you’ll get insight into our work!
As we previously detailed in our investigation, Piroska was admitted to the emergency department at Szent Imre Hospital in September 2024 because she was experiencing sharp, radiating back pain, shortness of breath, and a fear of dying. However, during the triage—the assessment of patients’ conditions upon arrival at the emergency room—the nurses did not perform an EKG, despite the woman’s request. Piroska’s condition continued to worsen at the hospital, and her relatives’ pleas for help were ignored. She felt the staff was wasting her time and that she could see a doctor more quickly through private medical services. Therefore, at 9:30 p.m., the elderly woman left the hospital at her own responsibility. She passed away at her home a few hours later.
Her son then filed a formal complaint to the NCPHP, which, after more than a year, launched an official investigation against the hospital in March of this year. Their investigation concluded that the failure to perform the EKG “can be constituted professional negligence,” because an EKG would have quickly revealed that Piroska was having a heart attack. According to the NCPHP, the fact that the nurse categorized Piroska as a “less urgent” case also can be considered professional negligence. This meant she would have had to wait as long as 6–8 hours for a medical examination and the results of her blood test. According to the assessment, her case should have been categorized as “urgent,” which would have required her to be seen by a doctor within half an hour.
The woman, who was struggling with pain, asked for pain medication, but she was not given any. “You should have taken that at home,” one of the nurses told her, according to Piroska’s son and her girlfriend, who were with her the entire time on the night of her death. As we wrote in our story, the NCPHP’s investigation does not address the nurse’s communication or the refusal of the painkiller. But it was revealed that the intensity of the pain was not recorded on the patient’s hospital documents. According to the authority’s investigation, the severe pain mentioned by the woman would have warranted an urgent categorization.
Szent Imre Hospital also investigated Piroska’s death back in 2024 but found no professional negligence. At the same time, it acknowledged the findings of the NCPHP’s March investigation and noted that “our institution does not consider inadequate communication with patients acceptable in any form.”
As a result of the woman’s death, the NCPHP imposed a fine of 500,000 forints (1361 euros in today’s exchange rate), and Szent Imre Hospital has since implemented several additional measures in its emergency care department aimed at improving patient safety. For example, between 10 a.m. and 10 p.m., two staff members—instead of just one—now simultaneously assess the condition of patients arriving at the emergency department. All professionals performing these assesments have the necessary qualifications, and the hospital is in the process of introducing regular training to keep their knowledge up to date, the hospital stated in response to an inquiry from Direkt36.
In addition, the head of the department or their deputy reviews and verifies the patients’ documents on a daily basis. Departmental meetings will also be held every two weeks to discuss day-to-day issues and more complicated cases. In its response to Direkt36, the hospital expressed its condolences to Piroska’s family– for the first time, nearly two years after her death.
Help us tell the truth in Hungary! Become a supporter now and you’ll get insight into our work!
Piroska’s son reacted with mixed feelings to the news of the fine and the hospital’s response. “It’s encouraging that the authorities have determined the responsibility of the hospital, even if the 500,000-forint fine imposed can be considered more of a symbolic amount in light of the serious failures,” he told Direkt36. The man appreciates the hospital’s gesture and is pleased that they want to improve patient safety. At the same time, he does not understand why the new measures were only introduced now.
“Were there no daily checks or controls in place on the ward before the tragedy? Until now, there has been no feedback, they haven’t addressed problematic cases, and they haven’t learned any lessons?” the man asked. He expressed his shock and concern, saying that it’s a frightening realization for him to think that such basic professional practices were apparently only recently put into place.